Compliments of the most aggressive rate-hike campaign in U.S. central bank history, we've seen a return to high-yield, low-risk assets.
Investors have been flocking to the short end of the curve for good reason -- the 2-year note backed by the perceived safety of the U.S. government is yielding 5%! However, after last week's selling pressure on the long end of the curve, the 10-year note and 30-year bond are paying investors over 4%.
With the potential for capital gains in addition to yield, this could prove to be one of the best times in history to be a U.S. bondholder.
Thus far in 2023, fixed income, and particularly long-dated Treasuries, have been held back by one of the best starts to the year for stock indexes in history, which attracted fresh investment dollars that might have otherwise gone toward fixed-income securities.
Widespread expectations for a recession and analyst forecasts for lower equities left investors and speculators on the wrong foot. Traditional investment portfolios were underweight equities coming into the year, and speculators recently held the largest net short position ever recorded in E-mini S&P 500 futures. We have seen most of the bearish speculative bets unwound and price action suggests that portfolio managers and individual investors gave into FOMO mentality (forcing money into stocks at elevated prices).
While we aren't outright bearish stock indexes, we believe most of the gains are already behind us. Since the Financial Crisis, investors have been spoiled with riches by non-stop government stimulus and easy-money policy.
After 2009, S&P 500 total returns have exceeded 20%, an abnormally high number of times. Further, with gains of 31.5%, 18.4%, and 28.7% in 2018, 2020, and 2021, respectively, investors' perception of normal is seemingly skewed. The long-term return in equities is in the 8% to 10% range, not the 20% to 30% range that many market participants appear to expect. This mentality has likely enticed sidelined dollars that would rationally be allocated to Treasuries to make their way into the stock market in search of higher returns.
Yet, a normalization in equity returns to reflect the lack of government stimulus would leave a risk-free 4% yield (assuming held to maturity) with a reasonable chance of appreciation looking quite attractive. After all, the current yield for holding the S&P 500 is about 1.5%, with substantial downside risk and minimal upside profit potential.
In addition to simple risk/reward analysis, this premise is corroborated by a few peripheral factors.
Let's take a look.
Seasonality
The Treasury market often relentlessly presses higher in July and August regardless of fundamentals. Thus far, the seasonal strength has been non-existent, but there are plenty of reasons for that to change.
Chart Source: MRCI
COT Report
We are only aware of one other instance in which speculators in the futures markets were as aggressively short the 10-year note futures as they are today. In fact, according to the latest COT Report (Commitments of Traders) issued by the CFTC (Commodity Futures Trading Commission), large speculators are holding the largest net short position in history. In 2018, the net short holdings peaked at nearly 680,000 contracts. At this time, large speculators are holding about 780,000 net short contracts.
Will we get a repeat of what we have witnessed in the E-mini S&P 500 in which the historically overcrowded bearish position unwound itself, causing an unusual rally? We think so.
Chart Source: Barchart
U.S. Dollar Weakness
All else being equal, a lower U.S. dollar promotes higher U.S.-denominated asset prices. The dollar index is on the brink of falling back into the pre-Ukraine-war trading range.
A decline and weekly close below 100.00 would seal the deal for a weaker dollar; this would act as a tailwind for most assets, particularly Treasuries.
Chart Source: QST
Inflation
The idea of runaway inflation ignited the original bond massacre of 2022. A year later, we know that inflation was peaking at precisely the time the markets were the most convinced the inflation cat was out of the bag and couldn't be tamed.
Inflation at 4% to 5% is still high compared to recent history, but in a world without aggressively loose monetary policy, 2% to 4% was considered acceptable. Perhaps we are simply falling back into a pre-Financial Crisis world of moderate inflation.
With this in mind, it is fair to assume Treasuries are probably underpriced.
Bottom Line
The stars are aligning for a contrarian trade in Treasuries.
With the CPI on tap in the coming days, there is room for near-term volatility, but the inflation trend has been lower, and there are few signs of that trend changing. Shipping container pricing has subsided, commodity markets have displayed deflationary behavior, and the CPI has consistently declined.
Perhaps the masses are positioned on the wrong side of the market at the wrong time.
