• Subscribe
  • Log In
  • Home
  • Daily Diary
  • Asset Class
    • U.S. Equity
    • Fixed Income
    • Global Equity
    • Commodities
    • Currencies
  • Sector
    • Basic Materials
    • Consumer Discretionary
    • Consumer Staples
    • Energy
    • Financial Services
    • Healthcare
    • Industrials
    • Real Estate
    • Technology
    • Telecom Services
    • Transportation
    • Utilities
  • Latest
    • Articles
    • Video
    • Columnist Conversations
    • Best Ideas
    • Stock of the Day
  • Street Notes
  • Authors
    • Bruce Kamich
    • Doug Kass
    • Jim "Rev Shark" DePorre
    • Helene Meisler
    • Jonathan Heller
    • - See All -
  • Options
  • RMPIA
  • Switch Product
    • Action Alerts PLUS
    • Quant Ratings
    • Real Money
    • Real Money Pro
    • Retirement
    • Stocks Under $10
    • TheStreet
    • Top Stocks
    • TheStreet Smarts
  1. Home
  2. / Investing
  3. / ETFs

Let's Comparison Shop These Two Consumer Staple ETFs

The Fed has spoken, and we know a rough ride likely awaits as the inflation battle rages on. So, here we'll compare the First Trust Consumer Staples AlphaDEX and the Consumer Staples Select Sector SPDR funds.
By MARK ABSSY
Aug 30, 2022 | 02:18 PM EDT
Stocks quotes in this article: FXG, XLP, SPY, ADM

Fed Chairman Jerome Powell delivered on Friday some sobering news. Investors intuitively knew things would be tricky, but many hoped that the Fed could engineer a soft landing. Friday saw those hopes dashed with Powell's commitment to attack inflation the only way the Fed knows how, regardless of the harm to the economy.

In fact, he warned, "reducing inflation is likely to require a sustained period of below trend growth.... While higher interest rates, slower growth, and softer labor market conditions will bring down inflation, they will also bring some pain to households and businesses."

Where can exchange-traded fund investors look to in this situation? I'm going to go back to basics to take a look at two "long-only" consumer staples funds. The first fund uses the original smart beta approach that helped turn First Trust into the ETF juggernaut it is today, the First Trust Consumer Staples AlphaDEX Fund  (FXG) . The second is the actively managed Consumer Staples Select Sector SPDR Fund  (XLP) .

For anyone wondering what I am talking about when I call XLP an active fund, I'd remind readers that all the Select Sector ETFs are based on the S&P 500 Index. If you read through the index methodology guide, SPX is an index that has no set rebalance schedule, and final security selection (including the decision to fast-track IPOs for inclusion) is based on the subjective decision of the S&P Selection Committee. If that's not the definition of active management, I don't know what is.

OK, back to the fund comparison.

As you can see in the table below, FXG has had a good year to date through Aug. 29, relatively speaking, against both XLP and the SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust (SPY) . Even in the current quarter-to-date period ending Aug. 29, it is still 1.04% over XLP, posting 4.02% compared to XLP's 2.98% returns. While FXGs 64 basis point (bps) expense ratio is clearly higher than XLPs 10 bps, you can see that over time, shareholders can make up that difference in returns.

Source: Factset, All You Can ETF

The Methodologies

I covered the methodology for XLP above except to add that Select Sector Indexes use a float-adjusted market capitalization weighting approach. Let's take a quick look at the methodology for AlphaDEX product indexes, identified as StrataQuant by index provider ICE Data Services. This approach was first developed in the mid-2000s and the first AlphaDex products were launched in 2007. The strategy uses the Russell 1000 Index as the base universe. From there, constituents in a given sector are evaluated using the following growth, and value factors:

Growth Factors:

  • 3-Month Price Appreciation

  • 6-Month Price Appreciation

  • 12-Month Price Appreciation

  • Price to Sales

  • 1-Year Sales Growth

Value Factors:

  • Price to Book Value

  • Price to Cash Flow

  • Return on Assets

Once all names have been scored and ranked, the top 75% of names are selected and grouped in quintiles based on rank. The constituent target is 40 names. The top quintile group is assigned an allocation of 33.33% (5/[1+2+3+4+5]), the second quintile is allocated 26.67% (4/[1+2+3+4+5]), and so on down the line. Constituents are equally weighted within each quintile.

The Results

I mentioned some returns above, but looking at some attribution is the best way to figure out what these funds are doing differently. First off, we have a 58% overlap between FXG's 40 holdings and XLP's 33 holdings, meaning that 58% of the names held in FXG are also in XLP. Not to confuse anyone, but from XLP's perspective, that figure is 68%. Suffice it to say that there are some material differences in security selection between these two funds. Another material difference comes from each fund's weighting methodology with XLPs float-adjusted market capitalization going up against FXGs modified equal-weight approach using the equal-weighted ranked quintile approach.

I ran some attribution for each fund from June 30 to Aug. 29 and found that while only one name was in both funds' Top 10 contributors to return over the period (Archer-Daniels Midland (ADM) ), a full eight names were held in common in the bottom 10 contributors to return. While anecdotal, these results seem to give a systematic selection and non-market capitalization-weighted approach to sector investing some advantage.

My Take

As you can see from the below below, FXG has done a good job over the years on a cumulative basis at least, outperforming both XLP and SPY.

Source: Factset, All You Can ETF

There are periods where the tables are flipped of course, but if you have a mid-to-long-term view that consumer staples has a place in your allocation, then perhaps FXG is worth a closer look.

Get an email alert each time I write an article for Real Money. Click the "+Follow" next to my byline to this article.

At the time of publication, Abssy had no position in any security mentioned.

TAGS: ETFs | Investing | Stocks | Food & Staples Retail | Consumer Staples

More from ETFs

Intel Tanks (Again), but I Spy 3 Other Charts That Look Pretty Darn Good

Bob Byrne
Jan 27, 2023 9:00 AM EST

The trio consists of a beverage seller, a connectivity company and a producer of advanced driving system technology.

In the Wild World of Crypto, a Wild Bitcoin Play Is the Best Call

Mark Abssy
Jan 26, 2023 1:24 PM EST

The situation for bitcoin investors right now is tough, but as we look at the crypto exchange-traded funds and the digital currency, I see one good 'option.'

Overcoming Microsoft, S&P Levels Off, Bank of Canada Wisdom, Mucho Data on Tap

Stephen Guilfoyle
Jan 26, 2023 7:28 AM EST

Plus, a look at Wednesday's wishy-washy market action, the Treasury yield curve, Chevron's coming earnings and Lael Brainard's possible exit from the Fed.

At 30, This ETF Is Still the Gift That Keeps on Giving

Mark Abssy
Jan 24, 2023 1:37 PM EST

Have your cake and eat it too, as we celebrate the birthday of this fund.

At Least Investors Can Have Trust in the Media

Bruce Kamich
Jan 23, 2023 12:53 PM EST

The Communication Services Select Sector SPDR exchange-traded fund shows promise, according to the charts.

Real Money's message boards are strictly for the open exchange of investment ideas among registered users. Any discussions or subjects off that topic or that do not promote this goal will be removed at the discretion of the site's moderators. Abusive, insensitive or threatening comments will not be tolerated and will be deleted. Thank you for your cooperation. If you have questions, please contact us here.

Email

CANCEL
SUBMIT

Email sent

Thank you, your email to has been sent successfully.

DONE

Oops!

We're sorry. There was a problem trying to send your email to .
Please contact customer support to let us know.

DONE

Please Join or Log In to Email Our Authors.

Email Real Money's Wall Street Pros for further analysis and insight

Already a Subscriber? Login

Columnist Conversation

  • 11:48 AM EST REAL MONEY

    Watch Doug Kass on the Daily Rundown!

    In today's Action Alerts PLUS Daily Rundown, Doug ...
  • 11:03 AM EST JAMES "REV SHARK" DEPORRE

    This Weekend On Real Money

    It's time to start using this power to build great...
  • 03:06 PM EST BOB LANG

    LEAPS Webinar

    This week, I offered a free webinar session talkin...
  • See More

COLUMNIST TWEETS

  • A Twitter List by realmoney
About Privacy Terms of Use

© 1996-2023 TheStreet, Inc., 225 Liberty Street, 27th Floor, New York, NY 10281

Need Help? Contact Customer Service

Except as otherwise indicated, quotes are delayed. Quotes delayed at least 20 minutes for all exchanges. Market Data & Company fundamental data provided by FactSet. Earnings and ratings provided by Zacks. Mutual fund data provided by Valueline. ETF data provided by Lipper. Powered and implemented by FactSet Digital Solutions Group.

TheStreet Ratings updates stock ratings daily. However, if no rating change occurs, the data on this page does not update. The data does update after 90 days if no rating change occurs within that time period.

FactSet calculates the Market Cap for the basic symbol to include common shares only. Year-to-date mutual fund returns are calculated on a monthly basis by Value Line and posted mid-month.

Compare Brokers

Please Join or Log In to manage and receive alerts.

Follow Real Money's Wall Street Pros to receive real-time investing alerts

Already a Subscriber? Login