Earnings Report Card for Small-Caps

On Friday, we took an updated look at the earnings report card for the large-cap stocks in the S&P 500. We are nearing the end of earnings season, and large-cap reporting is looking OK. There were definitely more upsides than downsides, and the magnitude of upsides were larger than the size of downsides. Although this can be a function of downside surprises being pre-announced, while upsides are reported later, nonetheless the trend was surprisingly positive. Now we turn our attention to small-caps. Two weeks ago, I compiled a mid-season report card for the Russell 2000, in order to discern if the underperformance of small-caps relative to large-caps this year is due to different earnings performance. Our findings at that time were that its upside earnings surprises and magnitude were better than the S&P 500's. However, the downsides were also worse! This is not unexpected, since the small-caps are more volatile than the large-caps. But we had not yet seen any earnings-based evidence that favored large cap over small. How is the Russell 2000 looking now? At this point, 73% of the Russell 2000 has reported and the table below highlights the winners and losers. Keep in mind that I favor earnings surprises over absolute numbers or even growth rates. To make money in stocks, you need a variant view relative to the market as a whole. You are not going to get paid to just run with the herd. I find surprises to be the best tell for where expectations are wrong. (This analysis uses the earnings-per-share (EPS) estimate as of six weeks ago, in order to screen out recent changes, pre-announcements and other manipulations.) This table shows the top twenty and bottom twenty surprises, by percentage, of the more than 1,453 reports so far for the R2000 names. I used just the 20 outliers to keep the size of the table manageable; email me here if you want the full list. Russell 2000 Second-Quarter Earnings View Chart » View in New Window » This far into reporting season, the trend in surprises is pretty stable. Of the names that have reported, 31% had upsides of better than 20%, which is identical to our last report card. Only 12% had downside surprises that were greater than 20%, which is essentially equal to the calculation we made last week. The magnitude of surprises is also favorable. The average upside surprise has been 85%, although that calculation is skewed by a dozen very large upsides (on a percentage basis). Removing the outliers with four-digit upside surprise percentages yields an average upside surprise of 53%, which is still very respectable. The average downside was negative 45%, which is bit worse than the negative 40% that we tallied last week. The new big winners skew toward the transports. FreightCar America (RAIL) knocked it out of the park, posting $0.44 vs. consensus of a penny. Teekay Tankers (TNK) put up $0.05 of EPS vs. break-even, which was also a meaningful surprise. Away from the outliers, Erickson (EAC) -- the aircrane, not the mobile phone company -- put up $1.10 vs. expectations of $0.12. On the downside, college book rental name Chegg (CHGG) is not chugging along. It posted a huge miss: a loss of $0.30 vs. expectations of near break-even. OncoMed Pharma (OMED) also did an OMG!, printing a loss of $0.22 when earnings of $0.03 were expected.

Earnings Report Card for Small-Caps

Since earnings season is winding down, let's look at the winners and losers.

Columnist Conversation

CPI Beats Expectations, But Maybe Not the 'Whisper'?

This Holding Lights Up With Strong Earnings

Jobs Report Reaction: Incredibly Strong, But Questions to Ask

COLUMNIST TWEETS

Please Join or Log In to manage and receive alerts.