• Subscribe
  • Log In
  • Home
  • Daily Diary
  • Asset Class
    • U.S. Equity
    • Fixed Income
    • Global Equity
    • Commodities
    • Currencies
  • Sector
    • Basic Materials
    • Consumer Discretionary
    • Consumer Staples
    • Energy
    • Financial Services
    • Healthcare
    • Industrials
    • Real Estate
    • Technology
    • Telecom Services
    • Transportation
    • Utilities
  • Latest
    • Articles
    • Video
    • Columnist Conversations
    • Best Ideas
    • Stock of the Day
  • Street Notes
  • Authors
    • Bruce Kamich
    • Doug Kass
    • Jim "Rev Shark" DePorre
    • Helene Meisler
    • Jonathan Heller
    • - See All -
  • Options
  • RMPIA
  • Switch Product
    • Action Alerts PLUS
    • Quant Ratings
    • Real Money
    • Real Money Pro
    • Retirement
    • Stocks Under $10
    • TheStreet
    • Top Stocks
    • Trifecta Stocks
  1. Home
  2. / Investing

My Defensive Stock Screen Hits a Speed Bump

The latest crop struggles in an up market.
By JONATHAN HELLER
Aug 10, 2016 | 12:00 PM EDT
Stocks quotes in this article: GLW, HP, JOY, FINL, TESO, CMI, IPHS, WDR, WLK, DDS, CTB, SSI

When it comes to stock screening, sometimes you win, sometimes you lose and sometimes you need to be patient in order to see how a concept plays out over time.

One of the handful of value-related screens, and perhaps the most stringent one that I run, is based on criteria developed by Ben Graham: "Stock Selection Criteria for the Defensive Investor."

Purists probably cringe at the alterations that I've made to the screen, but some were necessary. And I've maintained this criteria set for years and have no to plans to alter it, despite recent trials.

  1. Adequate size: We are using minimum sales of $500 million on a trailing 12-month basis. (Graham called for minimum sales of $100 million and total assets of at least $50 million.)
  2. Strong financial condition: The company must have a current ratio -- current assets divided by current liabilities -- of at least 2 and long-term debt must be less than working capital.
  3. Earnings stability: The company must have positive earnings for the past seven years (Graham used a minimum of 10 years).
  4. Dividend record: The company must have paid a dividend for the past seven years (Graham used 20 years).
  5. Earnings growth: Growth must be at least 3% compounded annually over the past seven years (Graham used a minimum increase in earnings per share of one-third over the past 10 years).
  6. Moderate price-to-earnings ratio: The stock must have traded at an average P/E of 15x or less in the past three years.
  7. Moderate ratio of price to assets: The price-to-earnings ratio times the price-to-book ratio must be less than 22.5.
  8. No utilities.

One of my earlier columns since rejoining Real Money late last fall revealed just four qualifying names: Corning (GLW) , Helmerich & Payne (HP) , Joy Global (JOY) and Finish Line (FINL) . That group has done well and is up about 43%, led by JOY's 82% run.

In January, I revealed the next vintage, which also included four names: Tesco (TESO) , Cummins (CMI) , Innophos Holdings (IPHS) , and Waddell & Reed Financial (WDR) . That group is up by more than 35% since, led by IPHS' 80% run, but hampered by WDR's 25% haircut.

The markets were changing rapidly in those days and so was the output of my Graham screen. In late March, I ran the screen again, which revealed four new names: Westlake Chemical (WLK) , Dillards (DDS) , Cooper Tire & Rubber (CTB) , Stage Stores (SSI) and one holdover from January, Waddell & Reed. Suffice to say, the third time has not been the charm in this case and that group of names has struggled and is down about 13%. That's horrendous performance in an up market. Just WLK is in positive territory and the two retailers in the group, DDS and SSI ,are both down more than 25%.

Smarter folks than I perhaps might alter their screen at this point and exclude retailers, and perhaps financials, as well. I am sticking with it as is -- good, bad and ugly.

In Friday's column, I'll reveal the current group of qualifiers and by way of a preview, there's just one new name, and three holdovers. It's rather boring in value land these days.

Get an email alert each time I write an article for Real Money. Click the "+Follow" next to my byline to this article.

 At the time of publication, Heller was long GLW.

TAGS: Investing | U.S. Equity | Stocks

More from Investing

Let's Shine a Light on Lucid Motors as It Slides Downhill

Brad Ginesin
Jul 2, 2022 1:00 PM EDT

LCID's market cap has been deflated, so is it now a bargain, or can it slip further?

Stop Wishing, Hoping and Praying and Take Control of Your Investing

James "Rev Shark" DePorre
Jul 2, 2022 10:00 AM EDT

The most powerful thing an investor can do is embrace the idea that they don't know what the future holds.

If You've Got Time, These Three Dividend Aristocrats Should Pay Off

Bob Ciura
Jul 2, 2022 7:30 AM EDT

There high-growth dividend stocks will be here over the long haul.

Welcome to Second Semester on Wall Street, Here's How to Make the Grade

Jim Collins
Jul 1, 2022 4:36 PM EDT

Think you can own big tech? You might just get an 'F' for that. Here's what will get you on the other side of this year.

We Got a Break, but the Heat Is Still On

James "Rev Shark" DePorre
Jul 1, 2022 4:22 PM EDT

A limited rally cooled some of the negativity on the market, but guess what's going to hit the fan soon?

Real Money's message boards are strictly for the open exchange of investment ideas among registered users. Any discussions or subjects off that topic or that do not promote this goal will be removed at the discretion of the site's moderators. Abusive, insensitive or threatening comments will not be tolerated and will be deleted. Thank you for your cooperation. If you have questions, please contact us here.

Email

CANCEL
SUBMIT

Email sent

Thank you, your email to has been sent successfully.

DONE

Oops!

We're sorry. There was a problem trying to send your email to .
Please contact customer support to let us know.

DONE

Please Join or Log In to Email Our Authors.

Email Real Money's Wall Street Pros for further analysis and insight

Already a Subscriber? Login

Columnist Conversation

  • 09:49 AM EDT JAMES "REV SHARK" DEPORRE

    This Weekend on Real Money

    Stop Wishing, Hoping, and Praying and Take Control...
  • 07:59 PM EDT PAUL PRICE

    Very Good Quarterly Numbers From Bassett Furniture (BSET)

    Bassett Furniture blew right through analysts es...
  • 04:41 PM EDT PAUL PRICE

    First-Half Results - Putrid; Second Half Results - Likely to Be Much Better

    It's great that we're done with June. 2022 mark...
  • See More

COLUMNIST TWEETS

  • A Twitter List by realmoney
About Privacy Terms of Use

© 1996-2022 TheStreet, Inc., 225 Liberty Street, 27th Floor, New York, NY 10281

Need Help? Contact Customer Service

Except as otherwise indicated, quotes are delayed. Quotes delayed at least 20 minutes for all exchanges. Market Data & Company fundamental data provided by FactSet. Earnings and ratings provided by Zacks. Mutual fund data provided by Valueline. ETF data provided by Lipper. Powered and implemented by FactSet Digital Solutions Group.

TheStreet Ratings updates stock ratings daily. However, if no rating change occurs, the data on this page does not update. The data does update after 90 days if no rating change occurs within that time period.

FactSet calculates the Market Cap for the basic symbol to include common shares only. Year-to-date mutual fund returns are calculated on a monthly basis by Value Line and posted mid-month.

Compare Brokers

Please Join or Log In to manage and receive alerts.

Follow Real Money's Wall Street Pros to receive real-time investing alerts

Already a Subscriber? Login