• Subscribe
  • Log In
  • Home
  • Daily Diary
  • Asset Class
    • U.S. Equity
    • Fixed Income
    • Global Equity
    • Commodities
    • Currencies
  • Sector
    • Basic Materials
    • Consumer Discretionary
    • Consumer Staples
    • Energy
    • Financial Services
    • Healthcare
    • Industrials
    • Real Estate
    • Technology
    • Telecom Services
    • Transportation
    • Utilities
  • Latest
    • Articles
    • Video
    • Columnist Conversations
    • Best Ideas
    • Stock of the Day
  • Street Notes
  • Authors
    • Bruce Kamich
    • Doug Kass
    • Jim "Rev Shark" DePorre
    • Helene Meisler
    • Jonathan Heller
    • - See All -
  • Options
  • RMPIA
  • Switch Product
    • Action Alerts PLUS
    • Quant Ratings
    • Real Money
    • Real Money Pro
    • Retirement
    • Stocks Under $10
    • TheStreet
    • Top Stocks
    • Trifecta Stocks
  1. Home
  2. / Markets
  3. / Rates and Bonds
  4. / Treasury Bonds

Insurance Stocks: Trouble With the (Yield) Curve

Investors may finally be catching up to it.
By ROGER ARNOLD Jul 26, 2016 | 03:00 PM EDT
Stocks quotes in this article: ALL, BRK.A, AIG, HIG, LNC, PGR, PRU, MET, ING, AZSEY, AXAHY, LYG

Doing macroeconomic analysis is similar to the work a meteorologist does in trying to anticipate atmospheric trends and make projections of what the weather will be like in a certain place at a certain time. There are an infinite number of variables to take into consideration, but even with technology it's impossible to predict the timing of weather events, and sometimes the expectations are just plain wrong. 

Even when they are wrong, though, there's empirical evidence as to what caused the prediction to be wrong; and that's the critical point at which the similarities between macroeconomic analysis and meteorology differ. 

One of the trends I wrote about many years ago was the negative impact a flattening U.S. Treasury yield curve would have on the stocks of the insurance industry. 

The oldest of those columns that's still in the archives is from almost exactly five years ago, "Insurance Sector Can't Survive a Flat Yield Curve." 

I followed up that column the next month with the columns "Cancel Your Insurance" and "There Is No Insurance for Insurance," in which I discussed the negative impact of a flat yield curve on the sector and cautioned investors to avoid it. 

Although the columns were well received by subscribers, the logic used in them, at that point in time, was largely known by investors and taken for granted. There was no great insight in them, just a cautionary reminder of what happens to insurance company operating margins when the spread between short rates and long rates shrinks. 

For most of the past five years, though, until about a year ago, even as spreads widened and shrank throughout that time, the stocks of most of the U.S.-based insurance companies rallied steadily. 

Aetna AET is up 185%; Allstate (ALL) 150%; Berkshire Hathaway (BRK.A) , American International Group (AIG) and Hartford Financial Services Group (HIG) all up about 90%; Lincoln National (LNC) and Progressive (PGR) 65%; and Prudential (PRU) about 30%. 

The only outlier has been MetLife (MET) , but even it's positive by 5%. 

By comparison, the returns of the European insurance companies has been dismal, with ING Groep (ING) , Allianz SE (AZSEY) , AXA SA (AXAHY) and Lloyds Banking Group (LYG) all posting five-year positive returns of between 2% and 6%. Still, though, they are positive. 

Throughout the past five years, this has been an aggravation to me because I've not been able to figure out why investors have been willing to park assets in these companies knowing the ability of them to continue to perform would be negatively impacted by the flattening yield curve. 

What appears to have occurred is that investors have assumed that the flattening of sovereign yield curves would not impact longer-term viability, and that during the interim they represented a safer place to park assets than in other economically sensitive sectors, especially since declining long-end yields caused the value of the securities already held to increase. 

Within the past year, though, the implications of flattening yield curves on the fundamental structure of the insurance industry seem to have finally settled in with investors. 

The European companies have been crushed by losses of between about 17% and 50%, and five of the nine U.S. companies are negative. The four with positive returns are all in the single digits. 

If the trend toward lower long-end U.S. Treasury yields as a positive indication for housing activity continues, as I've been writing about recently, it should cause the stocks of the U.S. insurance companies to follow the lead of the European ones. 

I offer this cautiously, though, because although investors appear to have become aware of the consequences of the flattening curve on insurance operations, and thus potential returns, I still cannot adequately appreciate why they did not begin to exhibit this understanding until about a year ago.

Get an email alert each time I write an article for Real Money. Click the "+Follow" next to my byline to this article.

At the time of publication, Arnold had no positions in the stocks mentioned.

TAGS: Investing | U.S. Equity | Treasury Bonds | Rates and Bonds | Markets | Stocks

More from Treasury Bonds

A Tide-Turning Rally Is Becoming More Probable

Guy Ortmann
May 23, 2022 9:29 AM EDT

The crowd is essentially entirely on the bear side of the boat.

Pressure Keeps Building for a Significant Market Rally

Guy Ortmann
May 20, 2022 10:04 AM EDT

Here's why we believe some selective buying is currently warranted.

Index Supports Fail as Data Say 'Buy'

Guy Ortmann
May 19, 2022 10:28 AM EDT

Insiders continue buying as traders extend short leverage.

No Place to Hide, Assessing the Beatdown, Dragon Breadth, Just Warming Up?

Stephen Guilfoyle
May 19, 2022 7:24 AM EDT

We ran, we ran all night and day... right back into U.S. Treasury securities, once again flattening the curve.

We're Raising Our Market Support Levels

Guy Ortmann
May 18, 2022 9:55 AM EDT

Sentiment continues to suggest rallies to resistance.

Real Money's message boards are strictly for the open exchange of investment ideas among registered users. Any discussions or subjects off that topic or that do not promote this goal will be removed at the discretion of the site's moderators. Abusive, insensitive or threatening comments will not be tolerated and will be deleted. Thank you for your cooperation. If you have questions, please contact us here.

Email

CANCEL
SUBMIT

Email sent

Thank you, your email to has been sent successfully.

DONE

Oops!

We're sorry. There was a problem trying to send your email to .
Please contact customer support to let us know.

DONE

Please Join or Log In to Email Our Authors.

Email Real Money's Wall Street Pros for further analysis and insight

Already a Subscriber? Login

Columnist Conversation

  • 02:24 PM EDT PAUL PRICE

    An Interesting Chart

    I'm betting heavily that stocks will be way up aga...
  • 10:10 AM EDT JAMES "REV SHARK" DEPORRE

    This Weekend on Real Money

    "Market Timing for Dummies"
  • 01:44 PM EDT STEPHEN GUILFOYLE

    Stocks Under $10 Portfolio

    We're making a series of trades here.
  • See More

COLUMNIST TWEETS

  • A Twitter List by realmoney
About Privacy Terms of Use

© 1996-2022 TheStreet, Inc., 225 Liberty Street, 27th Floor, New York, NY 10281

Need Help? Contact Customer Service

Except as otherwise indicated, quotes are delayed. Quotes delayed at least 20 minutes for all exchanges. Market Data & Company fundamental data provided by FactSet. Earnings and ratings provided by Zacks. Mutual fund data provided by Valueline. ETF data provided by Lipper. Powered and implemented by FactSet Digital Solutions Group.

TheStreet Ratings updates stock ratings daily. However, if no rating change occurs, the data on this page does not update. The data does update after 90 days if no rating change occurs within that time period.

FactSet calculates the Market Cap for the basic symbol to include common shares only. Year-to-date mutual fund returns are calculated on a monthly basis by Value Line and posted mid-month.

Compare Brokers

Please Join or Log In to manage and receive alerts.

Follow Real Money's Wall Street Pros to receive real-time investing alerts

Already a Subscriber? Login