• Subscribe
  • Log In
  • Home
  • Daily Diary
  • Asset Class
    • U.S. Equity
    • Fixed Income
    • Global Equity
    • Commodities
    • Currencies
  • Sector
    • Basic Materials
    • Consumer Discretionary
    • Consumer Staples
    • Energy
    • Financial Services
    • Healthcare
    • Industrials
    • Real Estate
    • Technology
    • Telecom Services
    • Transportation
    • Utilities
  • Latest
    • Articles
    • Video
    • Columnist Conversations
    • Best Ideas
    • Stock of the Day
  • Street Notes
  • Authors
    • Doug Kass
    • Bruce Kamich
    • Jim Cramer
    • Jim "Rev Shark" DePorre
    • Helene Meisler
    • Jonathan Heller
    • - See All -
  • Options
  • RMPIA
  • Switch Product
    • Action Alerts PLUS
    • Quant Ratings
    • Real Money
    • Real Money Pro
    • Retirement
    • Stocks Under $10
    • TheStreet
    • Top Stocks
    • Trifecta Stocks
  1. Home
  2. / Investing
  3. / Consumer Discretionary

Health Care Names Pressure Other Insurance, Retail Stocks

The trend will continue unless retail sales, job creation and incomes rise faster,
By ROGER ARNOLD Jun 09, 2015 | 05:00 PM EDT
Stocks quotes in this article: MET, AET, PGR, ALL, CI, ANTM, UNH, PRU, AIG

I wrote in a column last October about the prospect for the performance of the stocks of companies in the insurance industry as the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (PPACA) began to be implemented.  

The defensive part of the strategy was and is based on the idea that compulsory reallocation of consumer-disposable income to low-multiplier-insurance purchases comes at the expense of every other sector of the economy. But the consumer retail sectors that cater to discretionary income are affected most importantly. 

As discretionary income decreases due to an increase in insurance consumption, retail sales fall and retail stocks along with them. This trend has been reflected mostly as positive for the insurance stocks and negative for the retail sales and retail stocks, as I last discussed a few weeks ago in the column, Health Care Expenses Complicate GDP. 

The four insurance companies I discussed in the insurance column in October were chosen for their size and distinct insurance sector focus. 

MetLife (MET) was chosen because of its concentration in life insurance, Aetna (AET) as representative of the health insurance sector, Progressive (PGR) for its concentration in property and casualty insurance and Allstate (ALL) for its participation in both life and health, (L&H) and property and casualty (P&C).

The expectation for the performance of the insurance stocks is a subset of the idea that an increase in insurance consumption comes at the expense of other sectors. That subset is that compulsory increases in health care consumption should also come at the expense of voluntary insurance, the largest component of which is life insurance. 

And that is what has occurred. 

Aetna has been the best performer of the group, with a stock price that has increased by 50% since October 28. MetLife, Allstate and Progressive are only up 4%, 4%, and 3%, respectively. 

The dichotomy in this performance is supported anecdotally by the idea that the implementation of the affordable care act is indeed causing a reallocation of personal consumption expenditures. And that is providing a drag on economic activity and future potential. 

This observation is further supported by the performance of the rest of the healthcare insurance sector with Cigna Corp. (CI), Anthem, Inc. (ANTM), and UnitedHealth Group Incorporated (UNH) up 50%, 25%, and 26% respectively since last October 28. 

On the other side, the relative underperformance of the rest of the insurance sector is also supportive of this idea. Life insurance company Prudential (PRU), is only up 1% since October 28, and P&C-focused American International Group (AIG) up 13%. 

All of this action is supportive of the overall trajectory thesis for economic activity. That holds that retail sales cannot increase due to this forced reallocation of income into low- multiplier-insurance consumption. And that is acting as a drag on economic activity and potential. 

Economic rebounds and cyclical growth starts traditionally with an increase in high multiplier consumer spending, the most important of which is housing. The forced reallocation of spending is also helping to cause potential first-time home buyers to indefinitely postpone purchases. 

But there is also another component of this, which I'm writing about for Wednesday's column. That is that younger consumers, the 18-to-34 year-olds, appear to be collectively choosing a lifestyle that places the consumption of experiences above that of things. This pattern is going to have a profound impact on the potential performance of stocks in the retail space. 

As for the insurance issue, though, the recent pattern of outperformance by the health care stocks vs. the rest of the industry, as well as the retail stocks broadly, is likely to continue. That will occur unless something causes retail sales, job creation and incomes to begin rising faster than has been the case over the past five years.

Get an email alert each time I write an article for Real Money. Click the "+Follow" next to my byline to this article.

At the time of publication Arnold had no positions in stocks mentioned.

TAGS: Investing | U.S. Equity | Consumer Discretionary

More from Consumer Discretionary

Cruise Operator Carnival Still Isn't a Stock I Want to Climb Aboard

Jonathan Heller
Apr 9, 2021 9:00 AM EDT

The window the company offered this week on its results and financial state continue to give this value investor pause.

Norwegian Cruise Line Finally May Be Cruising Toward Higher Prices

Bruce Kamich
Apr 6, 2021 9:01 AM EDT

However, the technical signals of the cruise line operator don't entirely indicate smooth sailing ahead.

2 Land Plays That Insiders Are Buying

Bret Jensen
Mar 31, 2021 8:30 AM EDT

Green Brick Partners and Limoneira Co. offer reasons to buy their shares beyond the recent insider purchases of stock.

Peloton Has Disappointed: Take Your Leave and Sell

Bruce Kamich
Mar 24, 2021 9:33 AM EDT

We're checking in on the PTON charts again.

Live Nation Entertainment Is Not Yet Ready for Prime Time

Bruce Kamich
Mar 22, 2021 12:44 PM EDT

Traders should let the correction in LYV play out on the charts and stage.

Real Money's message boards are strictly for the open exchange of investment ideas among registered users. Any discussions or subjects off that topic or that do not promote this goal will be removed at the discretion of the site's moderators. Abusive, insensitive or threatening comments will not be tolerated and will be deleted. Thank you for your cooperation. If you have questions, please contact us here.

Email

CANCEL
SUBMIT

Email sent

Thank you, your email to has been sent successfully.

DONE

Oops!

We're sorry. There was a problem trying to send your email to .
Please contact customer support to let us know.

DONE

Please Join or Log In to Email Our Authors.

Email Real Money's Wall Street Pros for further analysis and insight

Already a Subscriber? Login

Columnist Conversation

  • 04:44 PM EDT PAUL PRICE

    Pretty Incredible + Hard to Believe

  • 11:18 AM EDT JAMES "REV SHARK" DEPORRE

    This Weekend on Real Money

    The 5 Pillars of Exceptional Trading
  • 08:05 AM EDT BOB LANG

    Bitcoin vs. Gold: Which Should You Invest In Now?

    Read my article TheStreet here!
  • See More

COLUMNIST TWEETS

  • A Twitter List by realmoney
About Privacy Terms of Use

© 1996-2021 TheStreet, Inc., 225 Liberty Street, 27th Floor, New York, NY 10281

Need Help? Contact Customer Service

Except as otherwise indicated, quotes are delayed. Quotes delayed at least 20 minutes for all exchanges. Market Data & Company fundamental data provided by FactSet. Earnings and ratings provided by Zacks. Mutual fund data provided by Valueline. ETF data provided by Lipper. Powered and implemented by FactSet Digital Solutions Group.

TheStreet Ratings updates stock ratings daily. However, if no rating change occurs, the data on this page does not update. The data does update after 90 days if no rating change occurs within that time period.

FactSet calculates the Market Cap for the basic symbol to include common shares only. Year-to-date mutual fund returns are calculated on a monthly basis by Value Line and posted mid-month.

Compare Brokers

Please Join or Log In to manage and receive alerts.

Follow Real Money's Wall Street Pros to receive real-time investing alerts

Already a Subscriber? Login