• Subscribe
  • Log In
  • Home
  • Daily Diary
  • Asset Class
    • U.S. Equity
    • Fixed Income
    • Global Equity
    • Commodities
    • Currencies
  • Sector
    • Basic Materials
    • Consumer Discretionary
    • Consumer Staples
    • Energy
    • Financial Services
    • Healthcare
    • Industrials
    • Real Estate
    • Technology
    • Telecom Services
    • Transportation
    • Utilities
  • Latest
    • Articles
    • Video
    • Columnist Conversations
    • Best Ideas
    • Stock of the Day
  • Street Notes
  • Authors
    • Bruce Kamich
    • Doug Kass
    • Jim "Rev Shark" DePorre
    • Helene Meisler
    • Jonathan Heller
    • - See All -
  • Options
  • RMPIA
  • Switch Product
    • Action Alerts PLUS
    • Quant Ratings
    • Real Money
    • Real Money Pro
    • Retirement
    • Stocks Under $10
    • TheStreet
    • Top Stocks
    • Trifecta Stocks
  1. Home
  2. / Investing

Buybacks by the 'Book': Book Value, Share Repurchase Strategy Outperforms

Finding undervalued companies that are buying back stock beats other metrics by a wide margin.
By TIM MELVIN Mar 24, 2016 | 04:00 PM EDT
Stocks quotes in this article: SBY, TDW, AIG, L, HES

As always, I have saved the best for last. All week I have been crunching numbers on share buybacks searching for what does and does not work when considering this as part of an investment strategy. It makes a lot of sense to do this as companies that repurchase their shares at attractive valuations are adding value to the corporation and ultimately (we hope) the stock price.

The trick is to avoid those being done at bad prices or for bad reasons. Buying back stock at high valuations or to manage earnings and disguise executive compensation can actually destroy value.

So far this week we have looked at using P/E (price/earnings) and EV/EBIT (enterprise value/earnings before interest and taxes) ratios to identify companies buying back stock at low valuations. Both strategies have delivered strong returns that beat the market, and a key part of the outperformance was that the approach plays great defense in bad markets.

But I saved my favorite metric for today. I have done well over my career buying stocks trading at less than book value and my study shows that corporations that repurchase their shares below book have also done well -- for the company and shareholders.

Using the same approach as the previous tests, I find that using book value to find undervalued companies that are buying back stock outperforms the other metrics by a wide margin. It also makes sense to drop the F-score requirement, as by itself buying back stock below asset value seems to act as a safety check. Using Piotroski F-scores (a measure of financial strength) produces a very small number of stocks, although it is worth noting that those it does find have very high returns. That's not to say that the list without using it finds a ton of stocks, as the average portfolio size is just 29 names.

This approach outperforms in both up and down market cycles and, like the others, does particularly well in bear markets. We can also gather a little predictive data from the model. If the number of qualifying stocks drops to single-digits it is time to be extraordinarily cautious. If you find 50 or more stocks that fit the book value, buyback criteria it is time to be bullish. If there are more than 100 stocks on the list it is time to break out margin, sell furniture, pets, your spouse's car, all your sports memorabilia not signed by Johnny Unitas or Brooks Robinson -- whatever it takes to raise cash and buy stocks.

The current portfolio has 40 stocks (see below), with an average market capitalization of $2.8 billion. The average buyback rate is 12.2% and CFOs are getting bargain prices as the average price-to-book value is just 75%.

This is a fantastic portfolio. Twenty-five percent of the portfolio is invested in "trade of the decade" community bank stocks. There are also several real estate-related companies that are activist targets with significant upside potential. One of my favorite long-term ideas is single-family REITs and Silver Bay Realty Trust (SBY), one of my favorite long-term single-family REITs, is in the book value buyback portfolio right now. Investment brokers have been hard hit this year and is another group I believe will see consolidation. There are handful of these names in the portfolio, too. It is an attractive mix of very cheap stocks.

My studies this week have shown that when companies buy back stock at low valuations based on earnings, cash flow and asset value, shareholders are very well rewarded. Stock buybacks are no different than any other stock purchase. Valuation matters and the cheaper you buy, the higher the potential returns.

One big surprise is that given the thousands of stocks on the various exchanges and the massive number of announced share repurchases there are actually very few buybacks done at attractive prices. All too much of this activity is to appease investors and manage earnings and I don't think that ends well for long-term shareholders.

I did run a combination test to conclude my buyback study. If you stuck to just purchasing stocks in companies that were buying back stock, and had either low P/E or EV/EBIT ratios or traded below book value with an F-score of 5 or higher you would be one of the top-performing investment managers around. In an average year you would have a portfolio that averaged 130 stocks. You would have positive returns in 15 of the last 17 years and outperformed the index in 12 of 17, including four of the last five.

Today, you would own a portfolio of 116 stocks with an average market cap of $6.9 billion, so you could actually run a decent-sized fund with this approach.

Get an email alert each time I write an article for Real Money. Click the "+Follow" next to my byline to this article.

At the time of publication, Melvin had no positions in the securities mentioned.

TAGS: Investing | U.S. Equity

More from Investing

As We Come Back From July 4, Market Fights a Hangover

James "Rev Shark" DePorre
Jul 5, 2022 4:22 PM EDT

After a rough start, we saw strength in some sectors that had taken it on the chin.

What's the Next Move for Crude Oil?

Bruce Kamich
Jul 5, 2022 3:30 PM EDT

A temporary break in oil prices, along with lower interest rates, could be a near-term positive for equity prices.

Can Nvidia Rally and Help the Tech Sector Recover?

Bruce Kamich
Jul 5, 2022 3:00 PM EDT

Why Tuesday could mark the start of a turnaround.

As Oil Hits the Fan, I See a Trading Opportunity

Mark Sebastian
Jul 5, 2022 2:48 PM EDT

Let's look at how to play Devon right now.

Tesla's Charts Are Resisting a Downside Break

Bruce Kamich
Jul 5, 2022 1:54 PM EDT

Here's what aggressive traders could do.

Real Money's message boards are strictly for the open exchange of investment ideas among registered users. Any discussions or subjects off that topic or that do not promote this goal will be removed at the discretion of the site's moderators. Abusive, insensitive or threatening comments will not be tolerated and will be deleted. Thank you for your cooperation. If you have questions, please contact us here.

Email

CANCEL
SUBMIT

Email sent

Thank you, your email to has been sent successfully.

DONE

Oops!

We're sorry. There was a problem trying to send your email to .
Please contact customer support to let us know.

DONE

Please Join or Log In to Email Our Authors.

Email Real Money's Wall Street Pros for further analysis and insight

Already a Subscriber? Login

Columnist Conversation

  • 12:01 PM EDT PAUL PRICE

    A Recent Director Buy in Children's Place (PLCE)

    Four of the most recent insider trades in Children...
  • 07:34 AM EDT PAUL PRICE

    A $525,000 Vote of Confidence on Macerich (MAC)

  • 09:49 AM EDT JAMES "REV SHARK" DEPORRE

    This Weekend on Real Money

    Stop Wishing, Hoping, and Praying and Take Control...
  • See More

COLUMNIST TWEETS

  • A Twitter List by realmoney
About Privacy Terms of Use

© 1996-2022 TheStreet, Inc., 225 Liberty Street, 27th Floor, New York, NY 10281

Need Help? Contact Customer Service

Except as otherwise indicated, quotes are delayed. Quotes delayed at least 20 minutes for all exchanges. Market Data & Company fundamental data provided by FactSet. Earnings and ratings provided by Zacks. Mutual fund data provided by Valueline. ETF data provided by Lipper. Powered and implemented by FactSet Digital Solutions Group.

TheStreet Ratings updates stock ratings daily. However, if no rating change occurs, the data on this page does not update. The data does update after 90 days if no rating change occurs within that time period.

FactSet calculates the Market Cap for the basic symbol to include common shares only. Year-to-date mutual fund returns are calculated on a monthly basis by Value Line and posted mid-month.

Compare Brokers

Please Join or Log In to manage and receive alerts.

Follow Real Money's Wall Street Pros to receive real-time investing alerts

Already a Subscriber? Login